Wilco - Yankee Hotel Foxtrot

@mdubno says:

Odds: 50:1
Phishiest Song:
Comments:



@ericwyman says:

Odds: 75:1
Phishiest Song: Heavy Metal Drummer
Comments: Not the right album for Phish. Another snooze fest for fest 8.



@tmwsiy says:

Odds: 50:1
Phishiest Song:
Comments:

The consensus?

Don't Count On It

Pearl Jam - Ten

@mdubno says:

Odds: 5:1

Phishiest Song: Alive

Comments: This would be a really interesting direction if Phish wanted to go out on the alt-rock limb (by limb by limb by limb by limb).

@ericwyman says:

Odds: 50:1

Phishiest Song:

Comments:

@tmwsiy says:

Odds: 5:1

Phishiest Song:

Comments: Would resonate well with so many fans.

The consensus?

Better not tell you now.

Nirvana - Nevermind

@mdubno says:

Odds: 10:1
Phishiest Song: Lithium
Comments: This cover would be a straightforward rocker.



@ericwyman says:

Odds: 12:1
Phishiest Song: Lithium
Comments: Easily an album that would get one of the biggest receptions. The opening chords to Teen Spirit would be lost on no one! Could Phish maintain the intensity?


@tmwsiy says:

Odds: 10:1
Phishiest Song:
Comments:


The consensus?

Beatie Boys - Hello Nasty

@mdubno says:

Odds: 40:1
Phishiest Song: Three MC's and One DJ
Comments: How the hell would they pull this off? They wouldn't is how.



@ericwyman says:

Odds: 75:1
Phishiest Song: Song For The Man
Comments: The two versions of Sabotage are the low point of Phish cover history. Terrible idea.



@tmwsiy says:

Odds: 20:1
Phishiest Song:
Comments:

The consensus?