Grateful Dead - American Beauty

@mdubno says:

Odds: 2:1
Phishiest Song: Truckin'
Comments:

@ericwyman says:

Odds: 100:1
Phishiest Song: Ripple
Comments: ZERO chance. Terrapin Station was their tribute.

@tmwsiy says:

Odds: 10:1
Phishiest Song:
Comments: A strong candidate, but would not be too surprising, a little trite?

The consensus?