AC/DC - Back In Black

@mdubno says:

Odds: 15:1
Phishiest Song: Hells Bells
Comments: This cover would be Fishman-heavy throughout the entire album. Revised odds up slightly from 12 to 15 because that's not going to happen.



@ericwyman says:

Odds: 30:1
Phishiest Song: Hells Bells
Comments: One of the pinnacles of hard rock. But and entire set of trey playing three chords?



@tmwsiy says:

Odds: 12:1
Phishiest Song:
Comments:

The consensus?

Very Doubtful

The Pixies - Come On Pilgrim

@mdubno says:

Odds: 40:1
Phishiest Song:
Comments:


@ericwyman says:

Odds: 50:1
Phishiest Song: Vamos
Comments: Considering they started at the same time as Phish, a great connection. But, at 20:28 this can't be any entire set. Even if you add Surfer Rosa.



@tmwsiy says:

Odds: 40:1
Phishiest Song:
Comments:

The consensus?

Very Doubtful

Rush - Moving Pictures

@mdubno says:

Odds: 25:1
Phishiest Song: Limelight
Comments: I'm a big Rush fan, and I think this musical costume would result in one happy Festgoer and 59,999 very pissed ones...and those are odds I don't like. But don't sleep on this album, Tom Sawyer is strong to start it off. Not sure if Phish could make it work trying to match Geddy's vocals.


@ericwyman says:

Odds: 25:1
Phishiest Song: YYZ
Comments: Seriously though, who raises their hand and says "Yeah I want to sing that"



@tmwsiy says:

Odds: 25:1
Phishiest Song:
Comments:

The consensus?

Reply hazy, try again

Michael Jackson - Thriller

@mdubno says:

Odds: 5:1
Phishiest Song: Wanna Be Startin' Somethin'
Comments: Mama-se, mama-sa, ma-ma-coo-sa...if Phish is ever going to play this album, this is the year to do it.


@ericwyman says:

Odds: 20:1
Phishiest Song: Wanna Be Startin' Somethin'
Comments: Probably the perpetual goof, but Indio would lose their shit.

@tmwsiy says:

Odds: 20:1
Phishiest Song:
Comments:

The consensus?